Comfort Colors Fit & Style Guide
Everything you need to know about sizing, shrinkage, and choosing the right Comfort Colors style for your custom apparel project.
What is Garment-Dyed Apparel?
Comfort Colors has built its reputation on garment-dyed apparel - a unique dyeing process that creates the brand's signature vintage, lived-in aesthetic. But what exactly does "garment-dyed" mean?
The Garment-Dyeing Process
Unlike traditional piece-dyed fabrics where the raw fabric is dyed before being cut and sewn, garment-dyed apparel follows a different path:
- Construction First: The shirt is fully cut, sewn, and assembled using unbleached, natural-colored fabric
- Dyeing Second: The completed garment is then immersed in dye baths and subjected to high heat and agitation
- Finishing: Multiple rinse cycles and enzyme washes create the soft, broken-in texture
The garment-dyeing process essentially pre-washes your shirt multiple times before you even receive it. This means the shirt you order is the shirt you'll keep - no surprises after the first wash.
Benefits of Garment-Dyed Apparel
- Pre-Shrunk: Minimal additional shrinkage after purchase (2-3% vs. 5-8% for regular shirts)
- Exceptional Softness: Feels like your favorite worn-in vintage tee from day one
- Unique Color Variations: Subtle variations create character and depth
- Faded Aesthetic: Colors appear naturally sun-faded and relaxed
- Vintage Look: Perfect for retro, bohemian, or casual brand aesthetics
Garment-dyed apparel may show slight color variations between items in the same order - this is normal and part of the artisanal charm. For exact color matching across multiple orders, piece-dyed alternatives may be more suitable.
Sizing & Fit Guide
Understanding Comfort Colors sizing is crucial for ordering the right fit. The brand is known for running larger and having a more relaxed silhouette compared to standard blank t-shirts.
Comfort Colors 1717 Size Chart
| Size | Chest Width | Body Length | Sleeve Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| S | 18" | 28" | 15.5" |
| M | 20" | 29" | 17" |
| L | 22" | 30" | 18.5" |
| XL | 24" | 31" | 20" |
| 2XL | 26" | 32" | 21.5" |
| 3XL | 28" | 33" | 22" |
| 4XL | 30" | 34" | 22.5" |
Size down for most wearers. If you wear a Large in Gildan 5000 or other standard blanks, you'll likely prefer a Medium in Comfort Colors. The relaxed fit and wider body mean you can comfortably go down one size without sacrificing comfort.
Fit Characteristics
- Relaxed Body: Wider through the torso than fitted brands like Bella+Canvas
- Boxy Silhouette: Less tapered at the waist, more vintage/classic cut
- Shorter Length: Body length runs slightly shorter than some competitors
- Wider Sleeves: Roomier sleeve openings than slim-fit alternatives
- Ribbed Collar: Sturdy 1x1 rib collar that holds its shape
Who Should Size Down?
Consider ordering one size smaller if you:
- Prefer a more fitted, modern silhouette
- Are between sizes in other brands
- Want the shirt to look more tailored after washing
- Are ordering for a younger demographic that prefers fitted looks
Who Should Order True to Size?
Order your normal size if you:
- Love the relaxed, oversized vintage aesthetic
- Want maximum comfort and airflow
- Plan to layer the shirt over long sleeves
- Are ordering for an older demographic that prefers roomier fits
Shrinkage Facts
One of the biggest advantages of Comfort Colors is the minimal shrinkage. Here's what you need to know:
Shrinkage Comparison
| Brand/Type | Expected Shrinkage | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort Colors (Garment-Dyed) | 2-3% | Pre-shrunk during dye process |
| Gildan 5000 (Standard) | 5-8% | Significant first-wash shrinkage |
| Bella+Canvas 3001 | 3-5% | Moderate shrinkage |
| 100% Cotton (Generic) | 5-10% | Varies widely by quality |
Where Shrinkage Occurs
When Comfort Colors does shrink slightly, it primarily affects:
- Length: Most noticeable shrinkage is in body length (up to 1")
- Sleeves: Sleeve length may reduce slightly
- Width: Minimal width shrinkage due to the dyeing process
Garment dyeing exposes the fabric to temperatures around 200°F (93°C) for extended periods. This heat treatment relaxes the cotton fibers and releases any tension that would cause later shrinkage. Essentially, your Comfort Colors shirt has already been through the equivalent of dozens of wash cycles before you receive it.
Popular Comfort Colors Styles
Comfort Colors offers a range of garment-dyed styles. Here are the most popular options for custom printing in Canada:
- Fabric6.1 oz Ringspun
- FitRelaxed
- SizesS - 4XL
- Colors70+
- Best ForGeneral use, events
- Fabric6.1 oz Ringspun
- FitRelaxed
- SizesS - 3XL
- Colors40+
- Best ForWorkwear, casual
- Fabric9.5 oz Fleece
- FitRelaxed
- SizesS - 3XL
- Colors50+
- Best ForFall/winter, schools
- Fabric9.5 oz Fleece
- FitRelaxed
- SizesS - 3XL
- Colors40+
- Best ForStreetwear, schools
- Fabric6.1 oz Ringspun
- FitRelaxed
- SizesS - 3XL
- Colors30+
- Best ForFall events, outdoor
- Fabric6.1 oz Ringspun
- FitRelaxed
- SizesS - 3XL
- Colors25+
- Best ForSummer, fitness
Browse our full selection of custom t-shirts and custom hoodies including Comfort Colors options.
Comfort Colors vs. Other Brands
How does Comfort Colors stack up against other popular blank apparel brands? Here's a detailed comparison:
| Feature | Comfort Colors 1717 | Gildan 5000 | Bella+Canvas 3001 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | 6.1 oz | 5.3 oz | 4.2 oz |
| Fit | Relaxed/Boxy | Classic/Standard | Fitted/Modern |
| Fabric | 100% Ringspun | 100% Cotton | 100% Ringspun |
| Softness | Very Soft | Standard | Very Soft |
| Shrinkage | 2-3% | 5-8% | 3-5% |
| Price Point | Premium | Budget | Mid-Range |
| Best For | Vintage/Lifestyle | Events/Promos | Retail/Fashion |
| Size Range | S - 4XL | S - 5XL | XS - 4XL |
When to Choose Comfort Colors
- You want a premium, vintage aesthetic
- Softness and comfort are priorities
- Your brand has a relaxed, bohemian, or lifestyle vibe
- You're selling retail merchandise or online apparel
- You want minimal shrinkage and consistent sizing
When to Choose Alternatives
- Gildan 5000: Budget-conscious projects, large events, promotional giveaways
- Bella+Canvas 3001: Fashion-forward brands, retail products, younger demographics
- Next Level 3600: Fitted looks with soft fabric at mid-range pricing
Comfort Colors Color Guide
Comfort Colors is famous for its extensive palette of muted, vintage-inspired colors. The garment-dyeing process creates unique tones that look naturally faded and sun-kissed.
Color Categories
Earthy Tones
Perfect for outdoor, nature, and organic brands
Ocean & Sky
Great for beach, coastal, and travel themes
Warm Tones
Ideal for fall events and cozy vibes
Best Sellers: Pepper (heathered charcoal), Blue Jean, Butter, Seafoam, and Ivory are consistently top sellers. For a classic look, Pepper and True Navy work with almost any design.
Color Matching Tips
- Screen Printing: Ink colors may appear slightly different on garment-dyed fabrics vs. standard shirts
- Pantone Matching: Allow for slight variation due to the dyed base color
- Order Samples: For exact color matching needs, request a sample before bulk ordering
- Batch Variation: Slight color differences between production runs are normal for garment-dyed products
Printing on Comfort Colors
Comfort Colors garment-dyed fabric accepts printing beautifully, but there are some considerations to keep in mind:
Best Decoration Methods
Screen Printing (Recommended)
- Works excellently on the ringspun cotton surface
- Vintage-style prints look particularly authentic
- Plastisol inks create vibrant, durable graphics
- Water-based inks maintain the soft hand-feel
- Discharge printing creates a no-hand-feel vintage effect
Embroidery
- The heavyweight fabric provides excellent stability
- Works well for logos, names, and smaller designs
- No concerns about color bleeding or fading
- Premium look that complements the garment quality
DTG (Direct-to-Garment)
- Good for full-color photographic prints
- May require pre-treatment on darker colors
- Colors may appear slightly muted on garment-dyed base
- Great for small runs and one-off designs
For the most authentic vintage look, consider discharge printing on darker Comfort Colors shirts. This process removes the dye rather than adding ink, creating a super-soft print that looks like it's been worn and loved for years.
Design Considerations
- Distressed Designs: Look particularly authentic on garment-dyed fabrics
- Simple Graphics: 1-3 color designs work beautifully
- Large Prints: Full-front or oversized prints suit the relaxed aesthetic
- Left Chest: Classic pocket-style placement is popular
- Back Prints: The heavyweight fabric handles large back prints well
Best Uses for Comfort Colors
Comfort Colors excels in certain applications where its unique aesthetic and premium quality shine:
Perfect For
- Beach & Resort Towns: The faded, coastal aesthetic is perfect for surf shops, beach bars, and vacation destinations
- College & University: Sororities, fraternities, and campus organizations love the vintage vibe
- Retail Merchandise: Brands selling apparel online or in stores appreciate the premium feel
- Music & Festivals: Concert tees and festival merch benefit from the worn-in look
- Outdoor & Adventure: Hiking groups, camping trips, and nature retreats
- Yoga & Wellness: Studios and retreats with relaxed, mindful aesthetics
- Cafes & Breweries: Lifestyle brands in the food and beverage space
- Family Reunions: Premium quality for cherished keepsake shirts
- Destination Weddings: Bach parties and wedding party gifts
May Not Be Ideal For
- Corporate Uniforms: The relaxed fit and vintage look may be too casual
- Budget Events: Higher cost per shirt affects large promotional orders
- Exact Color Matching: Batch-to-batch variation can be problematic
- Fitted Looks: The boxy cut doesn't suit slim/athletic aesthetics
- Bright/Neon Colors: The garment-dye process creates muted tones only
Explore our custom sweatshirts for Comfort Colors fleece options, or browse tank tops for summer alternatives.
Care Instructions
Proper care will keep your Comfort Colors garments looking great for years. Here's how to maintain them:
Washing Guidelines
- Temperature: Wash in cold water (30C/86F or less)
- Cycle: Use gentle or normal cycle
- Colors: Wash with like colors, especially for first few washes
- Turn Inside Out: Protects printed designs from abrasion
- Avoid Bleach: Never use chlorine bleach on garment-dyed items
- Skip Softener: Fabric softener isn't needed - they're already soft!
Drying Guidelines
- Tumble Dry Low: Use low heat setting
- Remove Promptly: Take out of dryer while slightly damp to prevent over-drying
- Air Dry Option: Hanging to dry extends garment life
- Avoid High Heat: High temperatures can cause additional shrinkage
Some color bleeding may occur on the first 1-2 washes, especially with dark or vibrant colors. Wash new Comfort Colors items separately or with similar dark colors until the excess dye is released.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Comfort Colors shirts are known to run large due to their relaxed, vintage fit. Most customers size down one size compared to Gildan or other standard brands. For example, if you wear a Large in Gildan 5000, you might prefer a Medium in Comfort Colors 1717.
Comfort Colors shirts experience minimal shrinkage (2-3%) because they are pre-shrunk during the garment-dyeing process. The high-heat dyeing essentially pre-washes the shirt multiple times. Any shrinkage that does occur is primarily in length rather than width.
Garment-dyed clothing is dyed after the garment is fully constructed, rather than dyeing the fabric first. This process creates a lived-in, vintage look with softer feel and unique color variations. It also pre-shrinks the garment and makes colors appear more muted and natural.
The 1717 is a standard crewneck t-shirt while the 6030 is a pocket tee version with the same fabric and fit. Both use 6.1 oz ringspun cotton with the signature garment-dyed treatment. Choose the 6030 if you want the added utility and classic look of a pocket.
Yes, Comfort Colors works well for screen printing, especially for vintage-style designs. The ringspun cotton provides a smooth printing surface. Note that colors may appear slightly different than on standard shirts due to the garment-dyed base. DTG and embroidery also work well on Comfort Colors.
Comfort Colors 1717 is available in sizes S through 4XL. The CC1566 (crewneck sweatshirt) runs S through 3XL. Youth styles are also available. Extended sizes (3XL, 4XL) may have limited color availability.
Wash Comfort Colors shirts in cold water with like colors and tumble dry low. While garment-dyed fabrics are more stable than piece-dyed fabrics, some color bleeding may occur in early washes, especially with darker colors. Avoid bleach and fabric softeners.
Comfort Colors costs more due to the specialized garment-dyeing process, which requires additional time, labor, and materials. The use of 100% ringspun cotton (vs regular cotton) and the premium softness and aesthetic justify the higher price point for many customers.
Ready to Order Comfort Colors?
Experience the premium quality and vintage aesthetic that makes Comfort Colors the choice of lifestyle brands and discerning customers.
Continue Exploring
Custom T-Shirts
From $8.99 — 100+ styles
Custom Hoodies
Pullover & zip-up styles
Custom Tank Tops
Perfect for summer
Explore More Resources
More Comfort Colors
Local Services
Buying Guides
- How to Choose the Right T-Shirt
- Pricing Guide
- Best Custom T-Shirts Toronto
- Best Custom T-Shirts Montreal
- Custom T-Shirt Printing Costs Canada
- Custom Apparel for Podcasters
- Screen Printing vs DTF vs Embroidery
- Logo Placement Guide
- Production Timelines
- Same-Day Printing
- Rush Screen Printing
- Next-Day T-Shirt Printing
Comparisons
Our Services: T-Shirt Printing · Screen Printing · Embroidery · DTF Printing · DTG Printing · Sublimation · Heat Transfer
More Canadian Cities: Kitchener · London · Windsor · Victoria · Surrey · Saskatoon · Regina · Halifax
