Skip to content
BLACK FRIDAY SALE25% off everything + free shipping Canada-wide over $250CODEBLACKFRIDAY25Tap to applyChristmas order-by dates
T-Shirt Elephant — Your Canadian Print Partner
View All Products5,000+ blank & custom styles
Free Web Stores Build your own apparel store — you design it, we print & ship, you keep the markup.
★ 1,068 Google reviews in the past year Printed in Canada Free ship $250+
Get a Quote Design Now
Home ›Resource Guide ›Screen Printing vs DTG

Screen Printing vs DTG: Which Should You Choose?

Compare screen printing and DTG printing side-by-side — costs, durability, quality, and when to choose each method

12 min read Updated October 2026
$14.10 vs $15.99
Screen (50 Gildan 5000s) vs DTG
50+ vs 1-49
Best Quantities
50 vs 30
Wash Durability
Setup vs No Setup
Fees

Quick Overview: Screen Printing vs DTG

Screen printing is best for bulk orders (50+ shirts) with simple designs, costs $14.10 per shirt at 50 and $12.30 at 100 for a one-colour print on a Gildan 5000, lasts 50+ washes. DTG is best for small orders (1-49 shirts) with complex designs, costs $15.99-$18.99 per shirt, lasts 30-40 washes. Neither method is universally better — choose based on quantity, design, and budget.

FeatureScreen Printing DTG Printing
Best Quantity50+ shirts1-49 shirts
Cost Per Shirt$14.10 at 50, $12.30 at 100 (one colour, Gildan 5000)$15.99-$18.99
Setup Fees$25.00 per colour per location$0 (no setup)
ColorsEach color adds costUnlimited colors
Durability50+ washes30-40 washes
FeelRaised, thickSoft, soaks in
Turnaround7-10 days3-5 days
Best ForBulk, simple designs, durabilitySmall orders, photos, complex art

Cost Comparison

Screen Printing Costs

  • Setup: $25.00 per colour per location (one-time, spread over the order and included in the prices below, a one-colour print on a Gildan 5000)
  • 50 shirts: $14.10 each
  • 100 shirts: $12.30 each
  • 500 shirts: $9.45 each
  • Example: 100 Gildan 5000 shirts, 2 colours = $5.20 blank + $7.10 print per shirt + $50.00 setup = $1,280.00 total ($12.80/shirt)

DTG Costs

  • Setup: $0
  • 1-24 shirts: $15.99-$18.99 each
  • 25-49 shirts: $12.99-$14.99 each
  • Dark fabrics: Add $1-2/shirt
  • Example: 10 shirts = $15.99/shirt = $159.90 total

Break-Even Point

DTG is cheaper for orders under 25-50 shirts. Screen printing becomes cheaper at 50+ shirts as setup costs spread across more units.

Durability: Which Lasts Longer?

Screen printing is more durable. Plastisol ink lasts 50+ washes without fading. DTG lasts 30-40 washes on 100% cotton.

Screen Printing Durability

  • Ink sits on top of fabric (raised layer)
  • 50+ washes when properly cured
  • Resistant to cracking and fading
  • Best for work uniforms, sports jerseys

DTG Durability

  • Ink soaks into fabric fibers
  • 30-40 washes on 100% cotton
  • Fades faster on blends and synthetics
  • Best for casual wear, event shirts

Winner: Screen printing for maximum durability.

Print Quality Comparison

Screen Printing Quality

  • Vibrant, saturated solid colors
  • Opaque on any fabric color
  • Raised, tactile feel
  • Less detail in gradients/photos
  • Consistent across thousands of shirts

DTG Quality

  • Photo-realistic detail
  • Smooth gradients and unlimited colors
  • Soft-hand feel
  • Less vibrant on dark fabrics
  • Slight variation between prints

Winner: Depends on design — DTG for photos, screen printing for solid colors.

When to Choose Each Method

Choose Screen Printing If:

  • Ordering 50+ shirts
  • Design has 1-4 solid colors
  • Need maximum durability
  • Want lowest cost per shirt
  • Printing on dark or synthetic fabrics

Choose DTG If:

  • Ordering 1-49 shirts
  • Design has photos or 5+ colors
  • Need rush turnaround (as fast as 2 business days)
  • Want soft-hand prints
  • No budget for setup fees

Still unsure? Order 1 sample with DTG to test your design, then scale to screen printing for bulk orders.

Ready to Print?

Get a free quote for screen printing or DTG

Ready to order? Explore our custom apparel
Custom T-Shirts Shop All T-Shirts Custom Hoodies
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Return Policy | Shipping Information | Sitemap | Accessibility | Intellectual Property
Copyright © 2026 H.A.S. Novelties Ltd. & H.A.S. Marketing Ltd. operating as T-Shirt Elephant. All Rights Reserved.

Trending Searches

Popular Categories